GLF Grain Elevator: Demolition Hearing - Part I

The City's Preservation Board voted unanimously on Thursday afternoon to table Ontario Specialty Contracting's request to demolish portions of the GLF/Wheeler grain elevator complex on Ganson Street.  The meeting room was packed with people who were on both sides of this emerging preservation issue involving one of the City's most important industrial heritage sites.
Ron Chapin - on the right
After an hour long discussion with Ron Chapin - from Ontario Specialty Contracting - the Preservation Board decided to table OSC's request to demolish parts "B" and "C" because the application was determined to be incomplete.   OSC presented a number of photographs - here, here and here - depicting a deteriorating structure.  The Preservation Board is asking OSC to provide an engineering study to determine the real condition of these structures.  In addition Henry Baxter, internationally recognized expert on concrete elevator design and structural condition has generously made his services available to assist the Preservation Board in making a decision about the future of GLF.  Henry Baxter's grandfather - A.E. Baxter - designed and built portions of GLF.    
Ontario Specialty Contracting - one of the City's premier demolition contractors - purchased portions of the GLF complex last October.  GLF is immediately adjacent to OSC's office and heavy equipment storage site on Ganson Street.  The photo below shows the portions of the GLF complex that OSC owns and the location - two single story buildings next door - of their headquarters.   Here's a bing map if you're not familiar with the area.  The remaining portion of the GLF elevator was last reported two years ago to be on the market for $3.5M.  Here's that story.  
The significance of Buffalo's remaining industrial heritage sites can not be emphasized enough.  Even in their neglected state they are stark and subtle reminders of our glorious past.  They are frequently studied and photographed.  German photographer Gerritt Engel was here in 90's and our collection of elevators was the subject of his first book and exhibit - Buffalo Grain Elevators.  Here's a recent video where he's interviewed about his work.
1994 photo (HAER credit) of  GLF from Chicago Street and a recent photo from the same location. 
More recently a number of community activists and organizations have taken a strong position on the deep cultural value of Buffalo's waterfront and the importance of these long neglected industrial heritage sites.  Make sure to watch the following video about this powerful and emerging voice describing how the City of Buffalo is being reinvented.  
Prior to Thursday's meeting I spoke with two community leaders who support the Ontario Speciality Contracting position and demolition.  Here's the short podcast (5:17) with Laura Kelly, Executive Director of the Old First Ward Community Association.  I also spoke with Peg Overdorf, who is the Executive Director of the Valley Community Center.  Here's that short podcast (3:24).   Riverfest Park - aka 'Peg's Park' - is located opposite GLF on the other side of the Buffalo River. 
The full recording of Thursday's Preservation Board hearing about the planned demolition of portions of the GLF Elevator is available - here (68:30).  
This preservation battle has only begun.  Support letters should be addressed to Preservation Board Secretary Michelle Brozek:  Buffalo Preservation Board - 65 Niagara Sq. #901 - Buffalo, NY 14202
building index • fixBuffalo flickr • creative class • shrinking cities • americansuburbX
spacing toronto • infrastructurist • inhabitat


Library Diva said...

The city needs a comprehensive plan for these grain elevators. Some are important parts of our heritage, some are deteriorating messes, and given their long history, I'm sure that there are some structures that contain both elements: portions that are historic and worthy of preservation, and portions that were added hastily, are not in good shape, and need to come down.

In Buffalo, there's often a feeling that we've been 'studied' to death, but I feel another study on these structures needs to be done to chart a course for preservation, reuse, and redevelopment down there. This issue with GLF is just the start of things.

A sound plan that has the support of the city and the community will attract good developers with smart ideas for that part of the city. A lack of one will mean more dissention and more demolition by neglect.

Story of Life said...

Fat people demolish, fit people renovate (see next story)

REACH said...

A nice story to be continued...

Just Let It Go said...

http://dornob.com/patchwork-orange-art-of-fixing-buildings-with-lego-blocks/ i saw this today and thought of you, fix buffalo. what if we started doing this to all the broken buildings? it would be awesome :)